Judge.me vs Stamped Which Review App Is Best for Shopify in 2025

Comparing Key Features of Review Apps

Explore the differences between Judge.me and Stamped for Shopify.

If you want the best review app for most Shopify shops in 2025, you should go with Judge.me. It stands out in the Judge.me vs Stamped debate because it nails the basics—great value, easy setup, and solid features. You get straightforward pricing, helpful support, and seamless integration. Whether you care about cost, functionality, or ease of use, you’ll find Judge.me fits most needs without the fuss.

Key Takeaways

• Judge.me is the top pick for most Shopify shops in 2025. It gives great value and is easy to use.

• Judge.me and Stamped both have free plans. Judge.me lets you send unlimited review requests. This is good for small shops.

• Stamped has more advanced features and customisation choices. This makes it better for bigger or growing brands.

• Judge.me has simple pricing with one flat fee. Stamped uses tiered pricing, so costs can go up as you grow.

• Both apps let you get text, photo, and video reviews. Judge.me gives video reviews in its paid plan. Stamped needs a higher plan for video reviews.

• Judge.me has quick and friendly customer support. Stamped gives detailed help for more complex needs.

• Think about what your shop needs before you choose Judge.me or Stamped. Each app has its own strengths.

• Try both apps on your shop. This can help you pick the best one for your business.

Judge.me vs Stamped Overview

Quick Verdict

You want a review app that works well and doesn’t break the bank. In the Judge.me vs Stamped debate, Judge.me comes out on top for most Shopify shops in 2025. It gives you all the essentials, keeps things simple, and offers great value. If you run a small or medium-sized store, you’ll find Judge.me easy to set up and use. Stamped has more advanced features, but you might pay extra for those. So, if you want a straightforward solution, Judge.me is your best bet.

Key Differences

Let’s look at what sets these two apart. You’ll notice some big differences when you compare Judge.me vs Stamped:

Tip: If you want more customisation and advanced marketing tools, Stamped might suit you better. If you want something simple and reliable, Judge.me is the way to go.

Who Should Use Judge.me

You should pick Judge.me if you want a review app that’s easy to use and doesn’t cost much. It’s perfect for:

• New Shopify stores that need quick setup.

• Shops that want to collect photo and video reviews.

• Owners who care about value for money.

• Anyone who wants fast support and clear features.

Judge.me helps you build trust with your customers. You don’t need to spend hours learning new tools. You get what you need, right out of the box.

Who Should Use Stamped

Stamped is a good choice if you want more than the basics. It works well for shops that want special features and more ways to change things. If your brand is growing or you care a lot about marketing, you will like the extra tools Stamped gives.

Here are times when Stamped is a smart pick for your Shopify shop:

• You want advanced marketing tools
  Stamped has loyalty programmes, referral rewards, and detailed analytics. These tools help you build a strong group of customers. They also help people return to your shop.

• You need more customisation
  You can change how your review requests look. Stamped lets you match your brand with more design choices.

• You run a larger or fast-growing shop
  If your shop is getting bigger, you may need more features. Stamped supports things like multi-store management and advanced integrations.

• You want to collect more types of user content
  Stamped lets you gather reviews, Q&A, Net Promoter Score (NPS), and Instagram curation. This helps you show your brand’s social proof in many ways.

• You value deep integrations
  Stamped connects with many apps, like email marketing, loyalty, and helpdesk platforms. This makes your work easier if you use lots of tools.

Note: Stamped is often best for brands that want to build a strong reputation and need more than just basic review collection.

In the Judge.me vs Stamped debate, pick Stamped if you want advanced features and have the budget. Stamped is great for established brands, marketing teams, and anyone who wants more than simple reviews.

Pricing

Judge.me Plans

You want a review app that is good value. Judge.me is simple to use. There is a free plan with no limit on review requests. You can ask customers for feedback as often as you want. This works even if your shop gets bigger. The paid plan costs £15 each month. It gives you extra features like video reviews and custom branding. You can also change how your requests look. You get faster support and more ways to make your reviews fit your shop.

Here’s what Judge.me gives you:

• Free plan: No limit on review requests, basic features, Judge.me branding.

• Paid plan (£15/month): Video reviews, coupons, full customisation, priority support.

You do not need to worry about extra fees for more orders or reviews. Judge.me gives you what you need if you are new or growing fast.

Stamped Plans

Stamped has more plans, but prices can go up as your shop grows. You start with a free plan, but it only covers 50 orders each month. If you want more features or have lots of orders, you must upgrade. Stamped has several paid plans. Each plan gives you more tools and options.

Here’s what Stamped offers:

Stamped lets you send review requests by SMS. You can give rewards for photos and videos. You get more display widgets and better integrations with higher plans.

Pricing Comparison

Let’s see how Judge.me and Stamped compare. Judge.me gives you unlimited review requests on every plan. You do not need to count orders. Stamped’s free plan is good for small shops. But you pay more as your shop gets bigger. If you want video reviews or special features, you need a higher Stamped plan.

Here is a table to show the differences:

Tip: If you want to save money and get unlimited review requests, Judge.me is best. If you want more marketing tools and do not mind paying more, Stamped has more choices.

Features

Review Collection

You want to collect as many reviews as possible. Both Judge.me and Stamped make this easy. Judge.me lets you send unlimited review requests, even on the free plan. You can ask for text, photo, and video reviews. This helps you build trust with new shoppers. Stamped also supports text, photo, and video reviews. It goes a step further by letting you collect Q&A, Net Promoter Score (NPS), and even Instagram content. If you want more types of user content, Stamped gives you extra options. For most shops, though, Judge.me covers all the basics you need to get started.

Display Options

How you show reviews on your shop matters. You want your reviews to look good and match your brand. Judge.me and Stamped both offer customisation, but they do it in different ways. Here’s a quick look:

With Judge.me, you can pick custom layouts and use rich snippets, even if you’re on the free plan. This means your reviews can help your shop show up better in search results. Stamped lets you display video reviews, Q&A, and social proof widgets. If you want more advanced display options, Stamped has more tools. For simple and effective review displays, Judge.me works well for most shops.

Automation

You don’t want to spend hours sending review requests or sharing reviews. Both apps help you automate these tasks. Judge.me automates email requests for both past and new customers. You can set it up once and let it run. Stamped uses in-email review forms, making it easy for customers to leave feedback without leaving their inbox.

Here’s how their automation features compare:

You can see that both apps help you save time. Judge.me vs Stamped comes down to what you need most. If you want simple automation and strong essentials, Judge.me is a great choice. If you want more advanced options, Stamped gives you extra tools for marketing and social proof.

Feature Comparison

When you look at Judge.me and Stamped, you want to know what each app can do. Both apps help you get and show reviews. But each one has its own special features. Let’s look at the main features so you can pick what works for your shop.

Tip: If you want things easy and want lots of reviews, Judge.me gives you what you need from the start. If you want more marketing tools and customisation as your shop grows, Stamped has more choices.

What You Get with Judge.me

• You can ask for as many reviews as you want, even on the free plan.

• You can collect text, photo, and video reviews.

• You can change how reviews look in your shop.

• You can use rich snippets to help your shop show up in search.

• You can share reviews on social media with one click.

• You can connect with loyalty and rewards apps.

Judge.me is quick to set up. You do not need to worry about limits or extra costs. The features cover all the basics. You can start building trust with your customers right away.

What You Get with Stamped

• You get advanced review types like Q&A, NPS, and Instagram curation.

• You get more ways to show reviews and more ways to change how they look.

• You can connect with more marketing and helpdesk tools.

• You can send SMS review requests and give rewards for user content.

• You can manage more than one shop if your brand is big.

Stamped is good if you want more than just basic reviews. You can use extra features to build a group of loyal customers and make your brand stronger.

Note: Think about what your shop needs most. If you want strong basics and easy setup, Judge.me is a great pick. If you want to grow with advanced features, Stamped gives you more ways to do that.

Both apps help you collect and show customer feedback. Your choice depends on if you want a simple tool or one with lots of extras for marketing and engagement.

Ease of Use

Setup

Getting started with a review app should feel easy. You want to spend less time setting things up and more time selling. Judge.me makes setup simple. You install the app, follow a few steps, and your review widgets appear on your shop. You do not need to know how to code. The app guides you through each part, so you can start collecting reviews quickly.

Stamped also offers a guided setup. You get a step-by-step wizard that helps you add review widgets and connect integrations. If you want more customisation, Stamped gives you extra options. You might need to spend a bit more time if you want advanced features. For most users, both apps make setup straightforward, but Judge.me feels quicker for beginners.

Tip: If you want to launch your review system fast, Judge.me is a great choice. Stamped suits you if you want to tweak more settings from the start.

Dashboard

You spend a lot of time in the dashboard. You want it to be clear and easy to use. Judge.me gives you a clean dashboard. You see all your reviews, requests, and settings in one place. You can filter reviews, reply to customers, and manage requests with a few clicks. The layout is simple, so you do not get lost.

Stamped’s dashboard looks modern and offers more tools. You see analytics, review requests, and user content. If you like data, you will enjoy the extra charts and reports. Stamped lets you dig deeper into customer feedback. You might need a little time to learn where everything is, especially if you use advanced features.

Here’s a quick table to show the differences:

User Experience

You want your review app to feel smooth every day. Judge.me keeps things simple. You click, you manage, you move on. The app loads fast and works well with Shopify. You do not need to read long guides. If you have questions, support answers quickly.

Stamped gives you more features, so the experience feels richer. You can customise more and see deeper insights. If you run a bigger shop, you might like the extra control. Stamped’s tools help you build a strong brand, but you may need to spend more time learning how everything works.

• Judge.me suits you if you want a hassle-free experience.

• Stamped fits you if you want more control and advanced options.

Note: Both apps work well with Shopify. Your choice depends on how much time you want to spend learning new tools and how many features you need.

Integration

Shopify Compatibility

You want your review app to work well with Shopify. Judge.me and Stamped both fit with Shopify easily. You can install them in just a few clicks. The widgets match your shop’s look, so you do not need to fix any code. Judge.me lets you add review forms, star ratings, and rich snippets without trouble. Stamped gives you widgets too. You can show reviews on product pages, collection pages, and even at checkout.

Both apps connect with your Shopify orders. They send review requests after each sale. This saves you time and helps you get more feedback from customers.

Tip: You do not need to be a tech expert. Judge.me and Stamped work right away with Shopify. You can spend your time growing your shop.

App Integrations

Most shops use more than one app to run things. Judge.me and Stamped connect with many popular tools. This helps you build a strong system for your shop. Here are some integrations you might use:

Both apps work with email marketing, loyalty, social media, and CRM tools. You can reward customers for reviews with Smile or Loyalty Lion. You can also share reviews on Facebook, Instagram, or X to show social proof.

Stamped gives you more integrations if you pay for higher plans. Judge.me lets you use many integrations even on cheaper plans. This is good if you want to save money.

API Options

If you like to change things or work with developers, you might want to use APIs. Judge.me and Stamped both have APIs, but they are a bit different.

1. Judge.me lets you collect and manage product reviews. You can use in-email review forms and share reviews on social media.

2. You can connect Judge.me with LoyaltyLion to give points for reviews. This helps you get more feedback from customers.

3. With Judge.me’s API, you can:

   • Make reviews automatically

   • Help your shop get more sales

   • Improve your marketing and SEO

   • Build a stronger group of customers

Stamped has API access too, mostly on enterprise plans. You can make custom workflows, sync data, and connect with other platforms. If you have a big shop or want more control, Stamped’s API gives you more options.

Note: If you want easy integrations and automation, Judge.me is a good pick. If you need special custom workflows, Stamped’s API might be better for you.

Support

Support Channels

When you run a Shopify shop, you want help that’s quick and easy to reach. Judge.me and Stamped both offer strong support channels, but they do things a bit differently. You get live chat with Judge.me, which means you can ask questions and get answers in real time. This is handy if you need help while setting up or fixing something. Stamped also gives you live chat, plus email support for more detailed queries. You can contact their teams through online forms if you prefer written help.

Here’s a quick look at what you get:

• Live chat for instant help

• Email support for longer questions

• Online contact forms

• Access to expert advice and industry partners

• 5-star customer support for automations

If you want fast answers, Judge.me’s live chat stands out. Stamped’s support feels more detailed, especially if you have complex needs. Both apps make it easy to reach someone when you need help.

Help Resources

You don’t always want to wait for a reply. Sometimes, you just want to find answers yourself. Judge.me and Stamped both offer helpful resources online. You get a knowledge base with guides, FAQs, and step-by-step instructions. These resources cover everything from setting up review widgets to automating requests.

Judge.me’s help centre is simple to use. You can search for topics and find clear answers. Stamped’s knowledge base goes deeper, with more articles and advanced tips. If you like learning on your own, you’ll find plenty of guides for both apps.

Tip: If you get stuck, check the help centre first. You might solve your problem faster than waiting for support.

Community

You’re not alone when you use Judge.me or Stamped. Both apps have active communities where you can share ideas and get advice. Judge.me has a user forum and social media groups. You can ask questions, swap tips, and see how other shop owners use reviews. Stamped also has a community, with webinars and partner events. You can join discussions and learn from experts.

If you like connecting with other users, you’ll find friendly groups for both apps. Judge.me’s community feels welcoming for beginners. Stamped’s events and webinars suit you if you want to dive deeper and grow your skills.

• Forums for sharing advice

• Social media groups for quick tips

• Webinars and events for learning

• Access to industry partners

Note: Joining the community helps you learn faster and get more from your review app. You can find new ideas and solve problems with help from other shop owners.

User Reviews

App Store Ratings

When you look at app store ratings, you get a quick sense of how happy users feel with each review app. Here’s what you’ll find in 2025:

• Judge.me holds a perfect rating. This shows that users trust it and find it reliable for their Shopify shops.

• Stamped gets high marks as well. Many users call it a brilliant choice for managing product reviews.

These ratings tell you that both apps deliver what they promise. You can feel confident picking either one, but Judge.me’s perfect score stands out if you want peace of mind.

User Feedback

You want to know what real users say about these apps. Here’s a look at the most common feedback for Judge.me and Stamped:

You see that users love the support and value they get, especially with Judge.me. Many mention how easy it is to use and how helpful the team feels. Some users do raise concerns about only showing positive reviews, which can make things look less genuine. Honest feedback, both good and bad, helps you build trust with your customers.

Popularity

Popularity matters when you choose a review app. You want to know that other shop owners trust the tool you pick. Judge.me leads the way in adoption. More Shopify stores use Judge.me than any other review app. You see this in the number of reviews and the high ratings it gets. People like how simple it is and how well it works for shops of all sizes.

Stamped also has a strong following. It attracts brands that want more advanced features and deeper customisation. If you run a larger shop or want to use marketing tools, you might see more shops like yours using Stamped.

Tip: If you want a review app that most Shopify users trust, Judge.me is the popular choice. If you want extra features and have a growing brand, Stamped could be the right fit.

When you compare Judge.me vs Stamped, you see that Judge.me wins on popularity and user satisfaction. Stamped stands out for shops that want more advanced options.

Value for Money

Cost vs Benefits

When you look at value for money, you want to know what you get for every pound you spend. Both Judge.me and Stamped offer strong features, but their pricing models work differently. Here’s how they compare:

• Stamped uses a tiered pricing model. You start with a free Lite Plan, then move up to Basic (£23/month), Premium (£59/month), and Business (£149/month). Each plan adds more features, so you can pick what fits your shop’s size and needs.

• Judge.me keeps things simple. You pay one flat fee for the paid plan, and you get all the essentials. There are no hidden costs or complicated tiers.

If you run a small shop, you might find the free plans enough. As your business grows, you may want more features. Stamped lets you scale up by moving to a higher plan. Judge.me gives you most features right away, so you do not need to worry about extra costs as you grow.

If you want a clear, predictable cost, Judge.me makes budgeting easy. If you like to choose features as you grow, Stamped’s tiered plans give you flexibility.

ROI

Return on investment (ROI) matters when you pick a review app. You want to see results for your money. Judge.me helps you collect unlimited reviews, even on the free plan. This means you can build trust with customers without worrying about limits. You get more reviews, which can lead to more sales.

Stamped gives you advanced features as you move up the pricing ladder. If you use these tools well, you can boost your brand’s reputation and encourage repeat business. Features like loyalty programmes and social proof widgets can help you get more value from each customer.

Here’s a quick table to show how ROI can look for different shop types:

You get the best ROI when you match your app choice to your shop’s needs. Think about what features will help you grow, not just what looks good on paper.

Scalability

Your shop might be small now, but you want to plan for growth. Scalability means your review app can keep up as you get more orders and customers. Stamped’s tiered pricing makes it easy to move up as your needs change. You can start small and unlock more features as you grow.

Judge.me gives you unlimited review requests from the start. You do not need to upgrade just because your shop gets busier. This makes it a strong choice if you want to keep things simple as you scale.

• Stamped adapts to your growth with more features at each tier.

• Judge.me offers a straightforward path, so you do not have to worry about changing plans.

If you want flexibility and lots of advanced tools as you grow, Stamped fits well. If you prefer a simple, predictable setup that works at any size, Judge.me is a safe bet.

You’ve seen how Judge.me and Stamped stack up. Judge.me gives you great value and easy setup. Stamped offers more advanced features for bigger brands. Here’s what you should do next:

• If you run a new or small shop, try Judge.me first.

• If you need more marketing tools, look at Stamped.

• Think about your budget and what features matter most.

Tip: Test both apps on your store. See which one feels right for you.

FAQ

Which app is easier to set up on Shopify?

You can set up both apps quickly. Judge.me feels simpler for beginners. Stamped gives you more options if you want to customise things from the start. If you want fast results, Judge.me is the easier choice.

Do both apps offer a free plan?

Yes, both Judge.me and Stamped have free plans. Judge.me gives you unlimited review requests for free. Stamped’s free plan limits you to 50 orders each month. If you want more, you need to upgrade Stamped.

Can I collect photo and video reviews with both apps?

You can collect photo reviews with both apps. Judge.me lets you collect video reviews on the paid plan. Stamped offers video reviews on higher plans. If you want video reviews at a lower cost, Judge.me is a good pick.

Which app is better for growing brands?

Stamped works well for growing brands that want advanced marketing tools and more customisation. Judge.me suits you if you want strong basics and easy scaling without extra costs. Think about your shop’s needs before you choose.

How do integrations compare between Judge.me and Stamped?

Both apps integrate with popular tools like Klaviyo, Mailchimp, and loyalty programmes. Stamped offers more integrations on higher plans. Judge.me covers most essentials even on lower plans. If you use many apps, check which integrations matter most to you.

Is customer support good for both apps?

You get fast, friendly support from both Judge.me and Stamped. Judge.me stands out for quick live chat help. Stamped offers detailed support, especially for advanced features. You can find guides and community help with both.

Which app gives better value for money?

Judge.me offers simple, flat pricing with unlimited review requests. Stamped uses tiered pricing, so you pay more as you add features. If you want predictable costs, Judge.me is the better value. Stamped is worth it if you need extra marketing tools.

Can I switch from one app to the other easily?

Yes, you can move your reviews between Judge.me and Stamped. Both apps offer import and export tools. You might need to follow a guide or ask support for help. Always back up your data before switching.

TangBuy: A Smarter Way to Dropship in 2025

If you're looking to stay competitive with dropshipping in 2025, speed and trend-awareness are key. TangBuy helps you stay ahead with real-time product trends, fast fulfilment, and factory-direct sourcing. With over 1 million ready-to-ship items, 24-hour order processing, and seamless Shopify integration, TangBuy makes it easier to test, scale, and succeed in today's fast-moving eCommerce landscape.

dropshipping.tangbuy.com

See Also

Comparing BigCommerce And Shopify: The 2025 Platform Showdown

Key Factors For eCommerce Success: BigCommerce Or Shopify 2025

Choosing Between Shopify And WooCommerce For Your Business

2025 BigBuy Dropshipping Review: User Ratings And Insights

Amazon Or eBay: The Best Platform For Sellers In 2025